SPORTS

Tom Brady vs. Patrick Mahomes: Tale of the tape as Buccaneers, Chiefs QBs square off in Super Bowl 2021

Super Bowl LV is a battle between two of the most dangerous teams in the NFL, not only because of their presence in the NFL’s season finale, but because of how they got there. The Kansas City Chiefs, who won it all after the 2019 season with one of the league’s most explosive offenses, are up against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, who air it out with as much gusto as anyone under the guidance of coach Bruce Arians. While the teams themselves have all kinds of intrigue, we all know the biggest reason people will be tuning in this Super Bowl Sunday: the quarterbacks. Rarely are we gifted such a high-profile showdown as this: Tom Brady versus Patrick Mahomes, the six-time champion against the reigning champion.

As we prepare for Brady versus Mahomes under the bright lights of Tampa’s Raymond James Stadium tonight, we’ve got everything you need to know about their matchup, from each QB’s postseason resume and Super Bowl record to how they’ve fared in head-to-head matchups. Buckle up, and get ready for arguably the most thrilling signal-caller showdown of the year.

Super Bowl LV is almost here, and you can watch it for free on the CBS Sports App. 

The Basics

QBAGESEASONHEIGHTWEIGHTCOLLEGEDRAFTED
Patrick Mahomes254th6-3230Texas Tech1st round (10th overall)
Tom Brady4321st 6-4225Michigan6th round (199th overall)

Physically speaking, Brady and Mahomes aren’t all too different in terms of size; neither is especially big, while Brady is a bit leaner. Their physical similarities, however, probably stop there. Mahomes is not a burner on the ground, clocking a 4.8-second 40-yard dash coming out of college, but the statuesque Brady has never been even a remote threat to run the ball. Correspondingly, Mahomes has made a name for himself as a reactionary big-play machine, using his mobility, effortless arm strength and unmatched penchant for acrobatic throws to post gaudy numbers. Brady, on the other hand, has lasted more than two decades mostly for his talent between the ears — a masterful attention to detail that’s kept him in shape, in command and rarely flustered as a “point guard”-style QB.

Neither Brady nor Mahomes came into the NFL with especially elite expectations. The Chiefs traded up to draft Mahomes 10th overall, but his Texas Tech resume was not the thing of superstars, with many scouts concerned about seemingly reckless ball-handling in a favorable offense. Mahomes also spent almost his entire rookie year on the bench behind Alex Smith. Brady, meanwhile, was even more of an afterthought, opening his rookie season as a No. 4 QB, playing just one game and only seeing the field extensively the following year because of a serious injury to starter Drew Bledsoe. Now, 20 years later, Brady is the furthest thing from an underdog thanks to his record-breaking, future Hall of Fame career, and Mahomes is unanimously one of the best QBs in today’s game.

Career Numbers

Brady has the obvious nod in all-time marks because of his time of service, but the reason these two are such an intriguing Super Bowl matchup is because, at their peak, they’ve both clearly been one of, if not the, best passer of their time. It’s hard to find a bad full-season performance from either QB.

QBSEASONSGAMESRECORDYARDSTDINTRATING
Patrick Mahomes44638-814,15211424108.7
Tom Brady21301230-6979,20458119197.3

Brady’s numbers look monstrous here, and that’s because they are; he ranks second in career passing yardage behind only Drew Brees and first in all-time passing touchdowns. But to put in perspective how unprecedentedly good Mahomes has been early on, he’s well on pace to surpass Brady’s career TD mark by his late 30s. Mahomes is averaging about 2.47 TD throws per game, which means he needs “only” about 189 games, or just under 12 more seasons of this kind of production, to catch TB12. That’s much, much easier said than done — especially considering the unpredictability of injuries and other circumstances — but it proves that these two QBs are either legends or legends-in-the-making.

Playoff Numbers

Just feast your eyes on this if you’re looking for QBs who know how to show up when the lights are brightest:

QBRECORDCONFERENCE TITLESYARDSTDSINTSRATING
Patrick Mahomes6-122,054172109.8
Tom Brady33-111012,248803889.9

Best Season

Both QBs boast MVP-caliber career years, which is no surprise considering they’ve got a combined five MVP awards between them:

  • Patrick Mahomes (2018): 5,097 yards, 50 TDs, 12 INTs, 8.8 YPA, 113.8 QB rating, 272 rushing yards, 2 rush TDs, 12-4 record
  • Tom Brady (2007): 4,806 yards, 50 TDs, 8 INTs, 8.3 YPA, 117.2 QB rating, 98 rushing yards, 2 rush TDs, 16-0 record

Worst Season

Again, not a whole lot of bad from either of these guys. For the sake of eliminating injury-shortened seasons or those spent on the bench, we’re only including years in which Brady or Mahomes played/started at least two games:

  • Patrick Mahomes (2019): 4,031 yards, 26 TDs, 5 INTs, 8.3 YPA, 105.3 QB rating, 218 rushing yards, 2 TDs, 11-3 record
  • Tom Brady (2002): 3,764 yards, 28 TDs, 14 INTs, 6.3 YPA, 85.7 QB rating, 110 rushing yards, 1 TD, 9-7 record

Super Bowl Resumes

This isn’t a fair comparison, considering Brady has 17 seasons on Mahomes, not to mention an additional eight Super Bowl appearances. But in the interest of reviewing their performances on the NFL’s biggest stage, we’ve got breakdowns below, courtesy of our Super Bowl quarterback preview at CBS Sports.

Patrick Mahomes

SEASONSUPER BOWLRESULTSTATS
2019XLIVW vs. 49ers, 31-2026-42, 286 yards, 2 TDs, 2 INTs, 78.1 rating

Funny enough, one of Mahomes’ worst statistical games of an otherwise Pro Bowl 2019 season came in the Super Bowl, his first — and record-breaking — championship, in which he threw a season-high two picks and posted his second-lowest passer rating (78.1) of the year. His second interception initially appeared to doom the Chiefs, who had fallen behind by 10 points in the third quarter against San Francisco, but that’s when he finally reversed course, reverted to MVP form and hit on several big plays to lead Kansas City to 21 unanswered points and the victory. His performance is a pretty good microcosm of his career thus far: Even when he doesn’t start well or the numbers don’t look pretty (granted, they often do), Mahomes’ penchant for acrobatic throws and timely touchdown drives make him a constant threat to steal a victory.

Tom Brady

SEASONSUPER BOWLRESULTSTATS
2018LIIIW vs. Rams, 13-321-35, 262 yards, 1 INT, 71.4 rating
2017LIIL vs. Eagles, 41-3328-48, 505 yards, 3 TDs, 115.4 rating
2016LIW vs. Falcons, 34-2843-62, 466 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT, 95.2 rating
2014XLIXW vs. Seahawks, 28-2437-50, 328 yards, 4 TDs, 2 INTs, 101.1 rating
2011XLVIL vs. Giants, 21-1727-41, 276 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT, 91.1 rating
2007XLIIL vs. Giants, 17-1429-48, 266 yards, 1 TD, 82.5 rating
2004XXXIXW vs. Eagles, 24-2123-33, 236 yards, 2 TDs, 110.2 rating
2003XXXVIIIW vs. Panthers, 32-2932-48, 354 yards, 3 TDs, 1 INT, 100.5 rating
2001XXXVIW vs. Rams, 20-1716-27, 145 yards, 1 TD, 86.2 rating

The closest any other QB has come to his record number of appearances (10, including this Sunday) is John Elway, who played in five. Unsurprisingly, Brady owns almost every major Super Bowl record in the book, from all-time passing yards to combined titles. He’s not been immune to big-game turnovers, throwing an interception in five of his nine Super Bowls to date, but he’s also been pretty darn good, never losing by more than one score and logging a 6-3 record on the NFL’s biggest stage. Perhaps most importantly, Brady’s always been notoriously efficient near the end of games, leading the Patriots to victory despite a 28-3 hole in Super Bowl LI, overcoming a 10-point deficit against Seattle in Super Bowl XLIX and taking the Eagles to the wire in Super Bowl LII.

Head-to-Head Results

Aha, the one you’ve been waiting for! Brady and Mahomes have clashed four times over the last three seasons, and fittingly enough, they enter Super Bowl LV knotted up in their all-time series, with Brady collecting two wins and Mahomes logging the other two:

  • Week 12, 2020 (Chiefs 27, Buccaneers 24): Mahomes led the way with 462 yards and three TDs, though Brady was just as active through the air, firing 345 yards, three TDs and two INTs in a tight loss that began with a 17-0 Kansas City lead.
  • Week 14, 2019 (Chiefs 23, Patriots 16): Neither QB was at his best in this one, with Mahomes throwing 282 yards, one TD and one INT; and Brady finished with just 169 yards, one TD and one INT for a lifeless Pats offense.
  • 2018 AFC Championship Game (Patriots 37, Chiefs 31): In this overtime thriller, Mahomes had 295 yards and three TDs to cap an MVP season, whereas Brady stole the “W” despite two INTs to go with 348 yards and one score.
  • Week 6, 2018 (Patriots 43, Chiefs 40): Early in Mahomes’ MVP season, he threw 352 yards, four scores and two INTs, while Brady went for 340 yards and one TD.

Fun Facts

What are these QBs’ go-to game-day foods? Who did they grow up idolizing? Here are a few parting nuggets:

  • Most notable favorite food: Ketchup (Mahomes), avocado ice cream (Brady)
  • Childhood sports hero: Tiger Woods (Mahomes), Joe Montana (Brady)
  • Career earnings$24.5 million (Mahomes), $263 million (Brady)
  • Childhood home: Tyler, Texas (Mahomes), San Mateo, California (Brady)

Per: CBS

%d bloggers like this: